Where to Stay in Niagara-on-the-Lake, Canada: The Best Hotels & Accommodations

As one of the most romantic destinations in Ontario, choosing where to stay in Niagara-on-the-Lake is always an exciting & enlightening experience while planning the ultimate trip to Southern Ontario.

The quaint historic town of Niagara-on-the-Lake sits on the shores of Lake Ontario and is the most popular getaway in the Niagara Region for couples and wine-lovers looking to explore the area’s world-renowned vineyards and wineries.

Thanks to its compact size, many of the best Niagara-on-the-Lake hotels are hemmed into its lovely 19th-century old town, one of the most well-preserved in all of North America.

Most of the accommodations in Niagara-on-the-Lake reflect the town’s heritage. Rather than run-of-the-mill hotels, many of the best places to stay in Niagara-on-the-Lake are bed-and-breakfast-style properties, occupying both perfectly preserved colonial buildings and modern houses.

Ready to get your Niagara-on-the-Lake accommodation search started? Pick the perfect place to stay with this guide to the best hotels in Niagara-on-the-Lake, Ontario…

Best hotels in Niagara-on-the-Lake

Prince of Wales Hotel

✓ Best luxury hotel in Niagara-on-the-Lake

Built in 1894, the legendary Prince of Wales Hotel hardly needs any introduction for travellers visiting Niagara-on-the-Lake. This lovely luxury hotel is among the most elegant hotels in the historic town, featuring regal rooms decorated with splendid Victorian furnishings, antiques, and artwork.

The luxurious amenities at the Prince of Wales Hotel are equally beguiling. For the ultimate in relaxation, retire to the palatial swimming pool and whirlpool area or enjoy a soothing massage at the on-site Secret Garden Spa.

Prince of Wales Hotel

If you’re all tuckered out from exploring the Niagara Region, spend an evening delighting a glass of local wine and French-inspired cuisine at the on-site Noble Restaurant or more casual local dining at the Churchill Lounge.

The Prince of Wales Hotel is perfectly situated in the heart of Niagara-on-the-Lake a few blocks from the Niagara River and Lake Ontario.

For sightseeing, the Fort George National Historic Site is less than 10 minutes from The Prince of Wales Hotel by foot. The Jackson-Triggs Estate Winery, one of the top-rated Niagara-on-the-Lake wineries, is just 5 minutes away by car.

  • Address: 6 Picton Street
  • Amenities: Free WiFi, coffee maker, flat-screen TV, swimming pool, hot tub, spa
  • Food & Drink: Noble Restaurant, Churchill Lounge

Oban Inn

✓ Best mid-range boutique hotel in Niagara-on-the-Lake

With a storied history dating back almost two hundred years, Oban Inn is one of the more interesting choices among the top hotels in Niagara-on-the-Lake. This popular boutique inn, originally built 1824, was perfectly reconstructed on its original foundations in 1993 after a fire destroyed it in its entirety nearly a year prior.

Oban Inn

While the rebuilt exterior still shows gleams of its former old-world charm, the interior of Oban Inn is, after a 2006 renovation, surprisingly chic and modern rather than baronial. You’ll find only 26 rooms at the Oban Inn, each showcasing their own unique contemporary charms.

Besides the well-appointed rooms, you’ll love the amenities at this 4-star boutique hotel. The grounds are set with lush English gardens leading to an outdoor swimming pool and hot spring. Inside, you’ll get to enjoy an on-site restaurant, fitness centre, and their full-service spa, OSpa.

  • Address: 160 Front Street
  • Amenities: Free WiFi, free parking, flat-screen TV, coffee maker, fitness centre, spa
  • Food & Drink: Oban Inn Restaurant

Explorer House Bed and Breakfast

✓ Best modern B&B in Niagara-on-the-Lake

Occupying a spacious modern house on a sleepy leafy cul-de-sac, the Explorer House Bed and Breakfast is among the best places to stay in Niagara-on-the-Lake for travellers looking for a quieter experience that’s still a short walk from the historic old town centre.

Explorer House Bed and Breakfast

There’s only a handful of rooms available at this beautiful home which means that you’re guaranteed a personal touch. The hosts of Explorer House Bed & Breakfast are gracious, catering to their guests’ every need and adding a local perspective to your Niagara itinerary.

Aside from its elegant suites, this homestay-style property sits just minutes from the oldest golf course in North America, several excellent hiking trails, and the beautiful Niagara River Parkway, one of Canada’s most beautiful fall destinations.

  • Address: 275 Anne Street
  • Amenities: Free WiFi, free parking, flat-screen TV, cable, spa bath, garden, shared lounge, outdoor terrace
  • Food & Drink: 3-course breakfast

Historic Wilson-Guy House

✓ Top-rated historic B&B in Niagara-on-the-Lake

Built in 1816 by a local innkeeper & merchant, the Georgian-style Historic Wilson-Guy House is even older than the nearby famed Prince of Wales Hotel. The B&B is listed as a Canadian heritage property and is one of the coolest historic accommodation options in Niagara-on-the-Lake.

While this popular downtown B&B has been renovated numerous times, it still shows off flashes of its original splendour including its three wood fireplaces, pine flooring, and sash windows. Throughout the property, you’ll also find examples of period furniture and artwork that hint at the hotel’s long history.

Historic Wilson-Guy House

Rooms at the Historic Wilson-Guy House are cozy & comfortable, but it’s the hospitality and the atmosphere that are most charming. Be sure to enjoy the morning tea & coffee and two-course home-cooked breakfast and the relaxing outdoor patio.

The Historic Wilson-Guy House features a great location, too. It’s less than a block from Queen Street, the centre of Niagara-on-the-Lake’s lovely historic old town.

  • Address: 177 Victoria Street
  • Amenities: Free WiFi, flat-screen TV, coffee/tea, terrace, patio
  • Food & Drink: Two-course breakfast

The White House Boutique B&B

Among the most unique hotels in Niagara-on-the-Lake, The White House Boutique B&B is an impressive place to stay from every angle. The hotel occupies an elegant and, unsurprisingly from the name, white house styled after a southern plantation home.

The White House Boutique B&B

The elegance of this bed-and-breakfast continues to the inside where you’ll be greeted by a mix of modern and classic furnishing and decor along with high ceilings. In the beautiful backyard space, you’ll be able to relax on the deck or under the pergola with a glass of wine or have a soak in the 7-person hot tub.

You’ll also dig the location of The White House Boutique B&B. The Niagara-on-the-Lake hotel is located less than a kilometre from the popular Jackson-Triggs Estate and within a short drive of the Fort George National Historic Site of Canada and The Shaw Festival Theatre.

  • Address: 481 Gate Street Unit 162
  • Amenities: Free WiFi, flat-screen TV, satellite, garden, patio, hot tub
  • Food & Drink: American & vegetarian breakfast

Butler Creek House

✓ Top hotel in Niagara-on-the-Lake for wine-lovers

For wine-lovers, there’s perhaps no better hotel or B&B than Butler Creek House. Located just 500 metres from the Jackson-Triggs Wintery and within close driving distance from Peller Estates and Konzelmann Winery, many of the Niagara Region’s best vintners are a short jaunt from this charming Niagara-on-the-Lake hotel.

Butler Creek House

Although the exterior sports a classic colonial look, the interior Butler Creek House offers a blend of a modern furnishings & decor with the odd traditional twist. Rooms here are spacious & bright, some offering luxurious extras like a private balcony with a garden view or a spa bath.

You reservation at Butler Creek House also includes a delicious full breakfast.

  • Address: 538 Butler Street
  • Amenities: Free WiFi, free parking, flat-screen TV, terrace
  • Food & Drink: Full breakfast

Pillar and Post Inn & Spa

✓ Best hotel in Niagara-on-the-Lake for couples

Long standing as one of the most popular hotels in Niagara-on-the-Lake, Pillar and Post Inn & Spa offers everything you need to make your stay in the Niagara region as dreamy as you’d imagined.

Pillar and Post Inn & Spa

The Pillar and Post Inn & Spa is chock-loaded with amenities that you won’t find at the small B&B-style Niagara-on-the-Lake hotels. During your stay, you’ll enjoy a wide menu of extras including an outdoor swimming pool, gym, and a full-service spa featuring an indoor saltwater pool, sauna, and hot springs pool.

If you’ve built up an appetite on your Niagara-on-the-Lake sightseeing journey, retire to The Cannery Restaurant for a delicious meal or tho the Vintages Wine Bar & Lounge for a nightcap.

  • Address: 48 John Street
  • Amenities: Free WiFi, flat-screen TV, outdoor swimming pool, indoor saltwater pool, hot springs pool, sauna, spa, 24-hour reception, yoga, meditation, fitness centre
  • Food & Drink: The Cannery Restaurant, Vintages Wine Bar & Lounge

Best Western Colonial Butler Inn

✓ Best budget accommodations in Niagara-on-the-Lake

In your accommodation search, you might have already noticed that Niagara-on-the-Lake hotels, especially those close to the centre, aren’t known for their budget-friendliness. One exception is the Best Western Colonial Butler Inn.

Best Western Colonial Butler Inn

As the only chain hotel near the historic town centre, Best Western Colonial Butler Inn may not generate much excitement, especially considering all the fantastic B&Bs nearby. But if you’re looking to save a few loonies & twoonies on your trip to Niagara-on-the-Lake, don’t discount staying here.

Unlike most of the properties in their brand, the Best Western Colonial Butler Inn occupies a large red-brick colonial-style mansion that jibes with the town’s historic vibe. The rooms are contemporary and spacious and a great choice for solo travellers, couples, and families.

Although the menu of amenities here isn’t as extensive as other hotels near the centre of town, the inn is home to a fitness centre, business centre, and a small sports bar for quick meals & drinks.

  • Address: 278 Mary Street
  • Amenities: Free WiFi, free parking, fitness centre, business centre
  • Food & Drink: Butler’s Sports Bar & Grill

Old Ivy Walk

If you’re looking to get charmed, you’ll absolutely love Old Ivy Walk the moment you lay your eyes upon it. Located steps from Lake Ontario, the Niagara River, and the heritage district, this delightful B&B is the perfect place to stay in Niagara-on-the-Lake to add a dash of history to your itinerary.

Old Ivy Walk

Aside from the property’s charming grounds and heritage architecture, the hotel’s superb location makes sightseeing a breeze. Fort George is less than 100 metres from Old Ivy Walk. You can also travel to several of the area’s top wineries, cideries, and breweries by bike or car in mere minutes.

  • Address: 28 Prideaux Street
  • Amenities: Free WiFi, free parking, garden
  • Food & Drink: Free breakfast

Brockamour Manor Bed and Breakfast

Located in a stately early-19th-century mansion, Brockamour Manor Bed and Breakfast is a Niagara-on-the-Lake accommodations gem. Although the hotel is just minutes from the centre of town, the property is set upon almost an acre of greenspace, making your stay feel like a secluded Niagara-on-the-Lake getaway.

Brockamour Manor Bed & Breakfast

From the elegant furnishings & decor to luxurious extras like in-room fireplaces & spa tubs, there’s a lot to love about Brockamour Manor. Perhaps most charming about a stay here is the chance to unwind with a glass of wine on one of the three covered porches to views of the well-manicured yard & gardens.

Within 10 minutes of the hotel, you’ll be able to get face-to-face with 28 of the finest wineries in Niagara-on-the-Lake including Peller Estates and Two Sisters Vineyards. There’s also a handful of biking & hiking trails in the vicinity as well including the Heritage Trail.

  • Address: 433 King Street
  • Amenities: Free WiFi, free parking, porch, terrace, fireplace
  • Food & Drink: 4-course breakfast

Ryan O'Rourke is a seasoned traveler and the founder & editor of Treksplorer, a fiercely independent guide to mid-range luxury travel for busy people. With over 20 years of extensive travel experience, Ryan has journeyed through over 50 countries, uncovering hidden gems and sharing firsthand, unsponsored insights on what to see & do and where to eat, drink & stay. Backed by his travel experience and in-depth research, Ryan’s travel advice and writing has been featured in publications like the Huffington Post and Matador Network. You can connect with Ryan on Twitter/X at @rtorourke.

DISCLAIMER: Treksplorer is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com and its affiliated international sites.

DISCLAIMER: You'll notice that from time to time I link out to recommended hotels/tours/products/services. If you purchase anything through these links, I'll receive a commission. It won't cost you anything extra, but it will help keep me trekkin' on and delivering more free (and unsponsored!) travel information to you. Thanks :)